Skip to content

We offer free shipping on all orders over $35.00. All tees and hats come with free shipping. Use code WELCOMEIN10 for a 10% discount.

Home
Benton's Beanies
Plush Parcels
Merch
About Us

Benton's Beanies

Account

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Pre-Loved/Owned Beanie Babies | Damaged Heart Tags

Pre-Loved/Owned Beanie Babies | Damaged Heart Tags

2003 Holiday Teddy

$3.00

Sale price $3.00 Regular price

Skip to product information

Pre-Loved/Owned Beanie Babies | Damaged Heart Tags

Pre-Loved/Owned Beanie Babies | Damaged Heart Tags

Pre-Loved/Owned Beanie Babies | Damaged Heart Tags

$3.00

Sale price $3.00 Regular price

Beanies 2003 Holiday Teddy American Blessing Bernie the Dog Blackie the Bear Blue Sherbet Bear Bones the Dog Bruno the Dog Canyon the Cougar Chip the Cat Clubby the Bear Crunch the Shark Doby the Dog Dotty the Dog Erin the Bear Fetch the Dog Fuzz the Bear Gigi the Dog Goatee the Goat Gracie the Swan Happy the Hippo Hissy the Snake India the Tiger Inky the Octopus Kicks the Bear Lefty 2000 Lips the Fish Luke the Dog Mac the Cardinal Millennium Bear Mom-e 2003 Bear Mystic the Unicorn Nanook the Dog Nibbly the Rabbit Niles the Camel Osito the Bear Patti the Platypus Peace w/ tag errors Peace Sign Bear Peanut the Elephant Pops the Bear Pouch the Kangaroo Pugsley the Dog Puffer the Puffin Rainbow the Iguana Righty 2000 Seaweed the Otter Slippery the Dolphin Smoochy the Frog Snip the Cat Snort the Bull Spangle the Bear Spot the Dog Spunky the Dog Stretch the Ostrich Strut the Rooster Tiny the Dog Twigs the Giraffe Tuffy the Dog USA the Bear Valentina the Bear Valentino the Bear Waddle the Penguin Weenie the Dog Wrinkles the Dog Ziggy the Zebra

These Beanie Babies have been declared damaged with bent or damaged Heart tags. All items here heavily discounted and you acknowledge the condition of the Heart tag upon purchase.

You may also like

Stay connected.

Be the first to discover new arrivals, collectible finds, special promotions, and the latest adventures from Benton’s Beanies.

Email

© 2026 Benton's Beanies, Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Terms of service

Search

Search

Products

1997 Holiday Teddy TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart & Tush Tag

1997 Holiday Teddy TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart & Tush Tag

$6.00

Regular price Sale price $6.00
1997 Holiday Teddy TY Beanie Buddies | Mint Heart Tush Tags

1997 Holiday Teddy TY Beanie Buddies | Mint Heart Tush Tags

$12.00

Regular price Sale price $12.00
1999 Signature Bear TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart/Tush Tag

1999 Signature Bear TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart/Tush Tag

$6.00

Regular price Sale price $6.00
2000 Signature Bear TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart & Tush Tag

2000 Signature Bear TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart & Tush Tag

$6.00

Regular price Sale price $6.00